I. The Prophecies Concerning Christ’s “Coming”
The key texts typically cited:
Matthew 24
-
Temple destroyed (24:2)
-
Abomination of desolation (24:15)
-
Great tribulation (24:21)
-
Sun darkened (24:29)
-
Son of Man coming on clouds (24:30)
-
Angels gathering the elect (24:31)
Luke 21
-
Jerusalem surrounded by armies (21:20)
-
Days of vengeance (21:22)
Daniel 7:13–14
-
“Son of Man coming with the clouds of heaven”
Revelation (written before or near 70 AD according to preterist dating)
-
Beast war
-
Temple measured (Rev 11)
-
Babylon judged
II. Jerusalem Destroyed — “Not One Stone Left”
Matthew 24:2:
“There shall not be left here one stone upon another…”
Historical Evidence
Josephus — Wars of the Jews (Book 6, Chapter 4)
He records that after the Temple burned:
“Caesar ordered that they should now demolish the entire city and temple… it was so thoroughly laid even with the ground… that there was left nothing to make those that came thither believe it had ever been inhabited.”
Roman soldiers pried apart stones to retrieve melted gold that had seeped between them during the fire.
Archaeology confirms:
-
Massive destruction layer
-
Burn layers in Jerusalem
-
Stones displaced and thrown down (visible today at Western Wall excavations)
This prophecy has extremely strong historical support.
III. Jerusalem Surrounded by Armies
Luke 21:20:
“When you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies…”
Josephus records that in 66 AD and then again in 70 AD, Roman legions surrounded Jerusalem.
Cestius Gallus first surrounded it (66 AD), then withdrew.
Titus returned with full force (70 AD).
This matches Luke’s warning that believers should flee when they see the encirclement.
Eusebius (4th century) records that Christians fled to Pella before destruction.
IV. Great Tribulation
Matthew 24:21:
“For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world…”
Josephus describes:
-
Famine so severe people ate leather
-
Internal civil war within Jerusalem
-
Cannibalism (Wars 6.3.4)
-
Over 1 million dead (Josephus’ estimate)
Whether or not the number is exaggerated, the suffering was catastrophic.
Josephus himself says:
“No other city ever suffered such miseries.”
That directly parallels Matthew 24:21 language.
V. Signs in the Sky — Angels and Armies?
Now we reach the controversial part.
Josephus records unusual celestial phenomena before 70 AD.
Josephus, Wars 6.5.3:
He describes:
-
A star resembling a sword over Jerusalem
-
A comet lasting a year
-
A bright light shining around the altar
-
The eastern gate opening by itself
-
Most dramatically:
“Chariots and troops of soldiers in their armor were seen running about among the clouds, and surrounding of cities.”
That is the famous passage.
This is not later legend — it is recorded by a Jewish historian writing within a decade of the destruction.
Tacitus (Roman historian) also mentions unusual portents:
Tacitus, Histories 5.13:
“In the sky appeared a vision of armies in conflict, of glittering armor.”
This is independent Roman corroboration.
These accounts describe what observers believed were heavenly armies in the clouds.
Now — what does Matthew 24:30 say?
“They shall see the Son of Man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory.”
Daniel 7 imagery:
“Coming with the clouds” is divine judgment language.
Cloud-coming in the Old Testament does not require physical descent to earth — it is often covenantal judgment language (Isaiah 19:1 — “The Lord rides on a swift cloud against Egypt”).
Preterists argue:
The “coming on clouds” in 70 AD was not a bodily descent,
but a judicial coming in judgment,
signified by the destruction of Jerusalem
and accompanied by reported celestial phenomena.
VI. “Angels Gathering the Elect”
Matthew 24:31:
“He shall send his angels… and they shall gather together his elect…”
The Greek word “angelos” means messenger.
Preterists argue this could refer to:
-
The Gospel spreading globally after Jerusalem’s fall
-
Apostolic missionary expansion
-
Not literal winged beings in the sky
This is one of the weaker historical correspondences — because there is no documentation of visible angels gathering people physically in 70 AD.
VII. The Timeline Statement
Matthew 24:34:
“This generation shall not pass, till all these things be fulfilled.”
This is one of the strongest preterist arguments.
If “generation” means the contemporaries of Jesus (roughly 40 years),
then 30 AD + 40 years = 70 AD.
That timing matches precisely.
VIII. Where the 70 AD Argument Is Strong
-
Temple destruction documented
-
Jerusalem surrounded by armies
-
Severe tribulation recorded
-
Celestial phenomena documented by Josephus and Tacitus
-
Time statement (“this generation”)
-
Old Testament cloud-judgment imagery
This makes 70 AD a serious candidate for fulfillment of at least much of Matthew 24.
IX. Where the 70 AD Argument Is Weak
If one reads:
-
1 Thessalonians 4 (resurrection of the dead)
-
1 Corinthians 15 (bodily resurrection)
-
Revelation 20 (final judgment)
as requiring literal global resurrection and visible return,
there is no historical documentation of:
-
Universal resurrection
-
Graves opening
-
Worldwide visible bodily return
-
Final judgment event in 70 AD
Full Preterism asserts those happened spiritually.
But historically, there is no record of global resurrection.
X. Historian’s Balanced Conclusion
If the question is:
Did dramatic prophetic events occur in 70 AD matching many of Jesus’ warnings?
Answer: Yes, strongly documented.
If the question is:
Is there historical documentation of literal Christ visibly descending on a cloud?
Answer: No direct documentation.
If the question is:
Were there recorded celestial phenomena interpreted as heavenly armies?
Answer: Yes — documented by Josephus and Tacitus.
If the question is:
Does 70 AD satisfy the “this generation” timeline?
Textually, yes.
Whether one concludes Christ “returned” in 70 AD depends entirely on whether:
-
One reads “coming on clouds” as judicial-symbolic language
OR -
One reads it as literal visible bodily descent.
No comments:
Post a Comment